Anti-Individualism and Knowledge (Contemporary Philosophical by Jessica Brown

By Jessica Brown

Modern philosophy of brain is ruled by way of anti- individualism, which holds subject's techniques are decided not just through what's inside of her head but in addition by means of facets of her setting. regardless of its dominance, anti-individualism is topic to a frightening array of epistemological objections: that it truly is incompatible with the privileged entry each one topic has to her techniques, that it undermines rationality, and, absurdly, that it presents a brand new path to a priori wisdom of the area. during this rigorous and persuasive learn, Jessica Brown defends anti- individualism from those epistemological objections. The dialogue has very important effects for key epistemological concerns akin to skepticism, closure, transmission, and the character of data and warrant.According to Brown's research, one major explanation for considering that anti-individualism is incompatible with privileged entry is that it undermines a subject's introspective skill to distinguish forms of concepts. So clinically determined, the normal specialise in a subject's reliability approximately her recommendations presents no sufficient answer. Brown defuses the objection by way of attract the epistemological concept of a proper substitute. extra, she argues that, given a formal figuring out of rationality, anti- individualism is appropriate with the thought that we're rational topics. in spite of the fact that, the dialogue of rationality offers a brand new argument that anti-individualism is in rigidity with Fregean experience. eventually, Brown indicates that anti-individualism doesn't create a brand new path to a priori wisdom of the realm. whereas rejecting ideas that limit the transmission of warrant, she argues that anti-individualists may still deny that we have got the kind of wisdom that will be required to take advantage of a priori wisdom of concept content material to achieve a priori wisdom of the global.

Show description

Read or Download Anti-Individualism and Knowledge (Contemporary Philosophical Monographs) PDF

Best epistemology books

The Epistemology of A Priori Knowledge

This quantity collects 4 released articles through the past due Tamara Horowitz and unpublished papers on determination conception: "Making Rational judgements whilst personal tastes Cycle" and the monograph-length "The Backtracking Fallacy. " An advent is equipped through editor Joseph Camp. Horowitz most well liked to acknowledge the variety of rationality, either sensible and theoretical rationality.

Philosophy of Perception: A Contemporary Introduction

The philosophy of belief investigates the character of our sensory reviews and their relation to fact. elevating questions on the wide awake personality of perceptual stories, how they permit us to procure wisdom of the realm during which we are living, and what precisely it truly is we're conscious of once we hallucinate or dream, the philosophy of conception is a transforming into niche in metaphysics, epistemology, and philosophy of brain.

John Locke and the Ethics of Belief

This booklet discusses the ethics of trust that Locke built within the final publication of his Essay: how we should govern our evaluations, particularly on concerns of faith and morality. Wolterstorff indicates that this crisis used to be instigated by means of the cave in of a once-unified ethical and non secular culture in Europe into warring factions.

Evidentialism and Epistemic Justification

Evidentialism is a well-liked thought of epistemic justification, but, as early proponents of the speculation Earl Conee and Richard Feldman admit, there are various components that needs to be built sooner than Evidentialism grants a whole account of epistemic justification, or well-founded trust. it's the goal of this ebook to supply the main points which are missing; right here McCain strikes earlier Evidentialism as an insignificant schema via declaring and protecting a full-fledged concept of epistemic justification.

Additional resources for Anti-Individualism and Knowledge (Contemporary Philosophical Monographs)

Example text

For example, she fails to put together the beliefs she would express by ‘Hesperus is visible now’ and ‘It is important to make as many observations of Phosphorus as possible’ to draw the conclusion she would express by ‘I should observe Hesperus now’. She would find it informative if told, ‘Hesperus is Phosphorus’. Frege explained such examples by claiming that the astronomer thinks of a single object, Venus, in two different ways, or via two different senses. One could take Frege as suggesting that the subject has two different descriptive ways of thinking of Venus.

1, sec. 7). Anti-individualism does not merely stress the role of the environment in acquiring concepts; it also holds that the content of a subject’s propositional attitudes is individuated partly in terms of environmental factors about which the subject may be ignorant or mistaken. As a result, antiindividualism may seem intuitively to threaten a subject’s a priori knowledge of the contents of her propositional attitudes. As the Twin Earth cases illustrate, a subject may have different thoughts in different environments, say, water thoughts on Earth and twater thoughts on Twin Earth.

At any time, Sally has exactly the same microstructure, she performs the same bodily movements, she has the same patterns of stimulation on her retinas, and so on. As before, she has a number of attitudes that she would express with the term ‘arthritis’, including the fear she would express with ‘I fear that my arthritis has spread to my thigh’. Burge argues that, in the counterfactual situation, Sally lacks the concept arthritis and instead has the concept tharthritis. In support of this interpretation, Burge points out that Sally herself would explain ‘arthritis’ by saying that it is a rheumatoid condition that occurs in joints and thighs.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.50 of 5 – based on 38 votes